Customer loyalty: how to win a second purchase

Opened parcel on a sofa with coral tissue paper, a mug and a loyalty card

Say that of 120 paid orders last quarter, 24, or 20%, came from people who had bought from you before. Start with that number if you are thinking about customer loyalty, though the percentage alone will not tell you how many of those returns were your doing. The rest is the things you do at the first order to make the second one come more easily. None of them needs a remarketing budget, but each will take some of your time.

How to build customer loyalty at the first order

A customer comes back for the same face cream or the same pet food and has to search for the product again, because their old confirmation has only a name, with no variant and no link. Over a detail like that the second purchase begins with searching. Open your order confirmation through their eyes and check whether it has the name with the variant and a link to the product.

While you are at it, separate in your emails the acceptance of the order from the dispatch. A message sent at the moment the label is created should not sound as if the courier has already collected the parcel, because the customer will start watching for it too early.

When someone asks about a date, answer about their specific order. For a delay, say what stage the case is at and when you will next be in touch, at a time you will keep, so that the customer does not have to start the same conversation again tomorrow. In CartBot a customer can check the status in the chat after giving the order number and the email address used at purchase, provided the shop platform makes that data available.

With goods that need care, such as leather shoes or a wooden board, include instructions that follow the manufacturer's recommendations. It is a practical thing the customer will use the first time they clean the item.

A second purchase and a return without obstacles

Walk the road from an old confirmation to a new basket. The link should lead to the same variant with the current price. If you no longer sell the product, say so on the page behind the link and suggest a successor if you have one.

A return is a separate matter. Show a clear procedure and answer questions about status, because someone who sent back shoes that were too small wants to know when the money will arrive. A smooth return does not guarantee another purchase. Making returns difficult so that the revenue stays in the till is ruled out anyway, since your obligations to the consumer are the same whatever your sales plan.

One more word about money. A returning customer costs you too, because you pay for service and payment fees, and if you sent them a code after the first order, for the discount as well. Subtract those costs before you compare their order with that of someone who came from a paid ad. A second purchase is often cheaper, but do not assume it in advance.

Reminders the customer has agreed to

Someone writes in the chat that they are waiting for size 39, or says “I'll come back after payday.” It is tempting to add them to your newsletter. Do not. Neither a question about a size nor an announcement of a return is consent to all future offers.

For emails and text messages with commercial information you need prior consent, which Article 398 of the Polish Electronic Communications Law requires (the rule that follows the EU ePrivacy framework). An earlier order does not replace it. On top of that come a legal basis for processing personal data and a simple way to opt out of messages.

If a customer asked to be notified when size 39 is back, record that request together with its scope and send exactly that notification. A newsletter with new accessories is a different kind of communication and the request for a notification does not cover it.

Be careful with reminders like “you're probably running out of pet food.” From one purchase of a bag you do not know how many dogs the customer feeds or whether they bought in bulk, so the timing of such a message is guesswork.

How do you measure repeat customers?

First decide whom you count as returning, for example a person with at least one earlier paid order. Then work out what share of all orders in the period came from such people, and keep to that definition. If in one quarter you count orders placed and in the next only those paid and shipped, the figure will change even though customers behave the same. Treat cancellations the same way every time.

Go back to the example from the start, 24 out of 120 orders. That share will rise even when the number of returns stands still and the number of new customers falls. So always record both numbers next to the percentage.

Look at the time since the first purchase too. For things bought once every few years, no return after a month says little about your service. Start with a category where another purchase makes sense for the customer, and with one fix, the order confirmation from which they can buy the same thing again without searching.

Try CartBot in your store

Quote within 24 h. No commitment, no card.